Chicago recently announced an 18 million dollar settlement with DoorDash after accusations that the food delivery giant used misleading practices affecting diners, local restaurants and delivery drivers. The agreement highlights a growing national conversation about transparency in delivery service platforms, customer service expectations, restaurant industry challenges and the responsibilities of companies that shape the modern delivery process.
The food service and food industry landscape has rapidly changed due to online ordering deliveries, delivery software adoption, expanding delivery fleets and rising customer expectations around speed, order accuracy and customer satisfaction. As platforms like DoorDash Drive, Uber Eats and other third-party delivery drivers expanded, so did questions about pricing clarity and customer communication.
This settlement underscores how crucial transparency is, not only for consumers but also for businesses and food delivery drivers who depend on fair practices to maintain customer loyalty, revenue drivers and consistent customer experience.
Why Chicago Filed a Lawsuit Against DoorDash
During the COVID-19 pandemic, residents relied heavily on food delivery as dining rooms shut down and local streets became quieter. With more people depending on delivery service platforms than ever, customer interaction and guest experience became central to how people perceived restaurants and delivery providers.
Chicago alleged that DoorDash misled consumers with hidden fees and unclear pricing structures. These included:
- Service fees
- Small order fees
- A 1.50 dollar “Chicago” fee
- Grouping these charges together with taxes
This created confusion and reduced customer satisfaction because people believed the costs were imposed by the government rather than the delivery platform.
Chicago also argued that the company did not clearly disclose that food prices on the app differed from those on in-person menus or digital menu listings on restaurant websites. For diners, this affected order verification, customer service expectations and overall customer experience.
Hidden Fees and Their Impact on the Delivery Process
Transparency in the delivery process is essential for maintaining customer loyalty. When charges are placed in ways that appear confusing, many users feel misled.
The lawsuit identified several concerns that affected the restaurant industry landscape, including:
1. Misleading Fee Grouping
Grouping platform fees with taxes limited a customer’s ability to understand true order costs. This affected the online reputation of both restaurants and delivery platforms.
2. Differences in Menu Pricing
Restaurants sometimes showed one set of prices on their digital menu or website, while higher prices appeared on the app. The city argued that this affected consumer trust.
3. Promotional Offers With Conditions
Some promotional deals required minimum order amounts, which were not always clear. This reduced customer satisfaction and created challenges in customer communication.
Restaurants Listed Without Consent
Chicago also accused DoorDash of listing certain local restaurants on its platform without permission. This created obstacles for restaurant owners who were unaware their menus were posted, which affected order accuracy, the delivery protocol, package management and food safety rules when hot and cold items were mishandled.
Unauthorized listings can damage a restaurant’s Yelp rating, online reputation, and influence key metrics such as table turnover, menu innovation and review management. In the long run, this affects revenue drivers within the foodservice industry.
The settlement requires DoorDash to cease listing restaurants without explicit consent.
Breakdown of the 18 Million Dollar Settlement
The settlement distributes funds across several groups involved in the delivery game and restaurant industry:
1. 4.5 Million Dollars for the City
This covers legal fees and supports city oversight on delivery service operations.
2. 3.25 Million Dollars for Unaffiliated Restaurants
These restaurants were listed without consent and are not currently featured on the app.
3. 5.8 Million Dollars in Marketing Credits
Eligible restaurants will receive marketing credits to offset previous commissions, supporting business growth, digital menu improvements and better customer service strategies.
4. 4 Million Dollars in Customer Credits
Customers with active accounts will receive credits starting January 28 to enhance customer experience and rebuild customer loyalty.
5. 500,000 Dollars for Delivery Drivers
Drivers working in September 2019 will receive compensation related to previous pay structure concerns.
This portion touches directly on issues like delivery times, shift hours, mileage reimbursement, mileage tracking, pay structure and other logistics that affected day-to-day responsibilities of food delivery drivers and restaurant delivery drivers.
DoorDash’s Additional Legal Matters
DoorDash is also facing:
- A Maryland lawsuit accusing it of unlawful fees
- A case involving DashPass and unauthorized subscription charges
These cases reflect industry-wide concerns about delivery software ethics, customer communication and subscription transparency.
Impact on Consumers and Customer Experience
Consumers expect clear information in online ordering deliveries. Confusing fee structures negatively affect:
- customer satisfaction
- guest experience
- customer loyalty
When diners feel misled, it affects the entire food delivery ecosystem including local restaurants, delivery drivers and even supply chains involved in food delivery.
Chicago’s settlement emphasizes clearer delivery protocols and transparent breakdowns of taxes versus platform fees. As customers increasingly rely on GPS maps for driver tracking, delivery equipment, delivery bags, insulated bags and security service considerations, transparency becomes essential.
Impact on Local Restaurants and the Restaurant Industry
Local restaurants already face challenges such as:
- food safety rules
- managing hot and cold items
- delivery deadlines
- review management
- CRM software usage
- loyalty programs
- email marketing
- social media platforms and online reputation
When restaurants are listed without consent, menu innovation suffers, digital menu accuracy declines and customer experience is disrupted.
The settlement forces platforms to adopt ethical practices that support the broader food & beverage sector.
Impact on Food Delivery Drivers
Delivery drivers face unique challenges including:
- long delivery distance
- weather conditions
- vehicle maintenance
- driver’s license requirements
- background checks
- motor vehicle record checks
- Slip, trip, and fall prevention
- pre-trip inspection
- Violence and robbery prevention
- personal protective equipment
- hand sanitizer requirements
- exterior light visibility
- magnetic sign usage
These factors shape the delivery process and ensure safety in Third-Party Delivery Drivers and In-House Delivery Drivers.
Past controversies over pay structure, minimum wage expectations, shift hours and employment contracts demonstrate why the driver payout was included in the settlement.
This also ties into traffic safety and Guidelines for Employers to Reduce Motor Vehicle Crashes, especially in urban settings with complex local streets.
Technological Influence on the Delivery Industry
Digital transformation in the delivery service world includes:
- delivery software
- delivery fleet management
- delivery protocol
- order accuracy systems
- online ordering deliveries
- AI-powered tools
- job board recruitment for drivers
- security solution enhancements
- prevention of online attacks
- QR codes for menus
- temperature-controlled trucks
- package management systems
As tech expands, companies must maintain higher standards of customer service and accuracy.
Why This Settlement Matters for the Future
This settlement pushes companies toward:
- clearer customer interaction
- transparent fee disclosures
- accurate digital menus
- ethical listing practices
- better customer communication
- stronger focus on customer loyalty
It has implications across the food delivery, food industry and logistics process.
About Ted Law
At Ted Law Firm, is a dedicated legal team built on integrity, clarity and client-focused guidance. We serve families across Aiken, Anderson, Charleston, Columbia, Greenville, Myrtle Beach, North Augusta and Orangeburg.The firm is committed to supporting individuals and businesses as they navigate complex legal concerns in an evolving environment. With a strong foundation in research, transparency and strategic thinking, Ted Law aims to help clients understand their rights and make informed decisions. The team values trust, communication and a results-driven approach that places the client’s needs at the center of every matter.Contact us today for a free consultation.
