In recent news, Geico, one of the largest auto insurers in the United States, is facing a class action lawsuit filed by policyholders. The complaint, filed on October 30 in federal court, alleges that Geico underpaid total loss vehicle claims, violating both state and federal consumer protection laws. This case has raised questions about the insurer’s valuation practices and how policyholders are compensated after total loss claims.
Background of the Lawsuit
Plaintiff Jamil Abdullah, along with three others, filed the class action against multiple Geico entities, including Geico Secure Insurance Co., Geico Casualty Insurance Co., Geico Advantage Insurance Co., and Government Employees Insurance Co. The plaintiffs purchased Geico auto insurance policies in Ohio and filed first-party claims after suffering vehicle damage.
When Geico declared their vehicles a total loss, the insurer was contractually obligated to pay the actual cash value (ACV) of the vehicles. However, the plaintiffs claim Geico reduced the ACV payment through an arbitrary “condition adjustment.” According to the lawsuit, this deduction was applied without inspecting the comparable vehicles used to calculate ACV, which could have led to underpayments.
The Condition Adjustment Controversy
The plaintiffs argue that the condition adjustment is a uniform deduction applied across the board, without considering the unique characteristics of each comparable vehicle. They claim this method violates the terms of the insurance policies and Ohio law, as it does not follow standard appraisal practices.
This practice has been described as misleading and deceptive, with allegations that it was designed to benefit Geico financially at the expense of policyholders. If proven true, this could have significant ramifications for policyholders who have been affected by total loss claims.
Legal Implications for Geico
This lawsuit is not the first legal challenge Geico has faced. Earlier this year, policyholders in Texas filed a lawsuit claiming the insurer misled customers regarding its accident forgiveness policy and unfairly raised premiums.
The Ohio class action case, Abdullah, et al. v. Geico Secure Insurance Co., et al., Case No. 1:25-cv-02339-CEF, is currently pending in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, Eastern Division. The plaintiffs seek to represent all Geico policyholders in Ohio who received an ACV payment based on a CCC One Market Valuation Report after their vehicle was declared a total loss.
What This Means for Policyholders
Policyholders who believe they have been underpaid by Geico may have an opportunity to join the class action or seek individual remedies. The outcome of this lawsuit could set a precedent for how insurers calculate ACV and the use of condition adjustments in claims. It may also encourage other states to scrutinize insurance practices more closely to ensure fair compensation for policyholders.
Steps Policyholders Can Consider
- Review your insurance policy and past claim statements for any discrepancies.
- Gather documentation related to your total loss claim, including communication with the insurer.
- Monitor ongoing updates regarding the class action lawsuit and related legal proceedings.
- Consult with a qualified legal professional to understand your options for recovery.
- Stay informed about your rights under state and federal consumer protection laws.
Conclusion
The Geico class action lawsuit highlights the potential for discrepancies in auto insurance claim practices and underscores the importance of transparency and accountability in the insurance industry. Affected policyholders should remain vigilant and explore their legal options to ensure they receive fair compensation for total loss claims.
About Ted Law
At Ted Law Firm, is committed to supporting individuals navigating complex legal challenges.We serve families across Aiken, Anderson, Charleston, Columbia, Greenville, Myrtle Beach, North Augusta and Orangeburg. With experience in insurance and consumer protection matters, Ted Law helps clients understand their rights and pursue justice in disputes with large corporations. Our goal is to guide clients through every step of the legal process while keeping their best interests at the forefront.Contact us today for a free consultation.
